#21
(This post was last modified: 03-18-2021, 10:10 PM by jbreakfield.)
(03-12-2021, 04:44 AM)jbreakfield Wrote: Ethos
Grooming Dept Kairos
A&E Kaizen 2
CBL Orion
House of Mammoth Tusk

I'm editing my post to add House of Mammoth's Tusk base to round out my top 5. 

Dragonsbeard, DanLaw and zaclikestoshave like this post
#22
So as a straight razor shaver and after taking a safety razor adventure over the last few months. I have to say any base is fine with a non- aggressive safety razor and easy to use. I even tried Barbisol and laughed at how easy it is to shave with a safety razor. Once you use a 12/8 to 8/8 extra hollow razor on your face though it is a whole nother experience. That said for straight razor shaving or if I am using my Charcoal Good lvl 3 OC then.....top bases are Tallow & Steel current base , Ariana & Evans K2, Daisho current base, Murphy & McNeil Kodiak Base, Wholly Kaw current base and Efros new base. All other soaps are so easy to use with even my Charcoal Goods lvl 3 SB to a Timeless .98 to a Muhle R41. Tried almost every brand out there in N. America, S. America, and Europe ( which is so far behind the US for quality minus a few Spainish and Italian artisans.) Kind of funny how some have recipes that are so old there going to have to change their ingredients by 2022 due to new laws that found certain ingredients to be harmful to humans.

Matsilainen, murphyandmcneil and zaclikestoshave like this post
#23

Trotter Handcrafts
Bellingham, Washington USA
(This post was last modified: 07-01-2021, 08:43 PM by Stubble Daddy.)
1. Tabac
2. La Toja
3. MDC
4. Palmolive
5. Moon (Union)

** Edit: adding “los jabones de joserra” to the top of the list. Amazing base.

I own all the latest and greatest bases from Grooming Dept, Ethos, Declaration Grooming, Noble Otter, B&M, Wholly Kaw, etc, etc... and for the most part, I still like the old classics more.

HighSpeed, DanLaw, Dave in KY and 5 others like this post
#24
My top bases in no particular order:

1. AE K2
2. BM Softheart
3. Mammoth Tusk
4. MM Kodiak
5. NO V3

Honorable mention:
6. DG Milksteak (tied with NO but I have more scents in NO that I love)
7. Zingari Man Sego

herbert7890, zaclikestoshave, Matsilainen and 2 others like this post
#25
I haven't used anything but Ethos for months. DG Milksteak, Zingari Man Sego, and A&E Kaizen V1 were pretty good, but definitely not the equal of Ethos. How much better is Kaizen V2?

cornbread, zaclikestoshave, DanLaw and 2 others like this post
#26
I don't own many soaps, so my selections may not be as good as others:

1) DG Milksteak
2) A&E Kaizen
3) B&M Excelsior
4) Catie's Bubbles (not sure it has a base name)
5) Southern Witchcraft (not sure it has a base name)

wyze0ne, zaclikestoshave and Matsilainen like this post
#27
(This post was last modified: 04-19-2021, 01:23 PM by cornbread.)
(04-19-2021, 12:30 AM)Mtt02263 Wrote: I haven't used anything but Ethos for months. DG Milksteak, Zingari Man Sego, and A&E Kaizen V1 were pretty good, but definitely not the equal of Ethos. How much better is Kaizen V2?

I get excellent shaves from most of my soaps. WK, DG, NO, BM, Moon. Kaizen V2(never tried v1) was my top until I tried Ethos for the first time a few days ago. I don't know if its my skin type, or the way I lather, or something specific about me but this soap is significantly better than anything else I have in my den. AS too. All alcohol-based AS I've tried will leave me with dryness. With Ethos AS I don't have to apply anything else.

With that said If I'm in the mood for a specific scent Ill just use any soap. Most modern soaps are excellent. Especially the artisans.

AQU, DanLaw, Mtt02263 and 3 others like this post
#28
Well, looks like I'll just be sticking with Ethos for awhile then lol. I do want to try the Colonia...

keto, Dragonsbeard and DanLaw like this post
#29
(04-19-2021, 02:55 PM)Mtt02263 Wrote: Well, looks like I'll just be sticking with Ethos for awhile then lol. I do want to try the Colonia...

I just ordered a Colonia set from Pasteur last night! Lavender was not really for me. Even though it is a perfect lavender scent I have a hard time getting over my association of the scent with cleaning supplies.

Succes is incredible. Excited for colonia.

Matsilainen, keto, Dragonsbeard and 1 others like this post
#30
1. Mammoth Tusk
2. Milksteak
3. Sego
4. Noble Otter v3
5. Stirling

keto likes this post


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)