favorite bay rum products

what's your favorite bay rum scented products out there?

I love the smell of Krampert's Finest AS. I haven't used his soap, but the AS is fantastic!

Captain's Choice and Mike's Natural.

While I consider my nose well educated and have sniffed fragrance since I was 15 years old, Bay rum is still a challenge for me to enjoy.

I do like Barrister & Mann Bay Rum shaving soap, but not sniffed directly from the container, but while used during the shave, the scent is lovely.

Will says the scent should be clove-less, but I still get clove from it.

The ones that are binned in my garbage.

Bay Rum is simply not a scent I enjoy, for some reason. I know it is extremely popular so this is just me.

I like the traditional clove based bay rums very much in AS (CC CO9T is a favorite). But, for soaps, my favorite is Dr. Jon's Anne Bonney, which has a black tea curveball take on the bay rum style (worth trying for those who dislike clovey bay rum and good performing soap in my book).

I just traded for a Bay Rum, Soap Commander. I like the scent, this being my first Bay Rum and have not shaved with it yet so we will see.

Mike's
Dominica
Great combination. IMO

Captain's Choice for me.

Cat o' nine tails from Captain's Choice is probably the only Bay Rum I don't hate. I'm not saying I really like the scent, but it's the first Bay Rum I have that I've used more than once. Love the warmth too. Not a sting or a burn so much as warmth. Feels great in the winter in my chilly basement bathroom.