Your top 20 shaving soaps ?

I no longer own 20 soaps as there are a few that I truly enjoy, so I decided to sell on those that were seeing little use. I now have a preference for tallow soaps

My current, and considered top soaps are:-

1. Vintage Floris (own No.89 and the Verbena stick)
2. Czech & Speake (own both)
3. Art of Shaving (all three tallow)
4. Vintage La Toja stick (tallow)
5. Ralph Lauren Safari (tallow)
6. Vintage L'Homme Scottish Fine Soaps (tallow)
7. D.R. Harris
8. Sir Irisch Moos stick
9. MWF
10. Geo. F. Trumper's Rose soap (2008)
11. C&E Mysore Sandalwood circa 1978.

I like Arko

And Bufflehead

1. Pannacrema Nuavia Blu
2. Pannacrema Nuavia Rossa
3. Reef Point Submariner
4. Soap Commander Serenity
5. Tabac
6. Soap Commander Endurance
7. Soap Commander Courage
8. WSP Tallow Gaelic Tweed
9. Reef Point Earl Grey and Ginger
10. Reef Point Admiralty
11. Barrister & Mann Latha Oceana
12. Beaver Woodwright Jolly Roger
13. Reef Point Dragons Blood
14. DR Harris Windsor
15. Saponoficio Varesino Felce Aromatica
16. WSP Tallow Matterhorn
17. Reef Point Peerless
18. Sapone di Paolo Agrume
19. Barrister & Mann Latha Taiga
20. Cella

For me it is a pretty short list if I leave out multiple scents and just list favorite brands.

1.) Stirling
2.) Soap Commander
3.) Chiseled Face
4.) Reef Point
5.) Tabac

I have a bunch of others that may or may not be replaced, and there are always more on the list to try. I have just been concentrating on using up some of the ones I have. These five brands probably make up 95% of my SOTD's.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

Here is my list as of April 2016 (not in any particular order):

1. Barrister & Mann
2. Nuavia
3. Czech & Speak
4. Savonniere du Moulin
5. Mystic Water
6. Le Pére Lucien
7. Saponificion Varesino
8. Mike's
9. P.160 Tipo Morbido
10. Valobra Tallow (own 4)
11. ABC
12. Klar Seifen/kabinett
13. Martin de Candre
14. Boellis Panama 1924
15. Vintage Crabtree&Evelyn Mysor Sandalwood
16. 3P
17. I Coloniali
18. MWF
19. Tabac
20. Vintage Yardley

I also very much appreciate the following shaving creams: XPEC original, SMN, ADP

Great lists on this thread! I'm still sketching out my own opinions, but for me Nuavia might top the list.

Favorites:

Mystic Water
Mike's Natural
PannaCrema Nuavia
Tabac/Irisch Moos
Valobra/C&S
Savonniere du Moulin

Honorables (re-buy worthy):

Klar Seifen
Cella (brick)
ABC
Le Pere Lucien
Dapper Dragon
Palmolive
La Toja
Arko
Gold Dach's
Mitchel's Wool Fat
JabonMan

I recently sold and pifed almost all of my soaps away. I just kept the best for me.  
Not close to 20 but...

MDC
LPL Apricot
Tabac
D.R. Harris
and now I have to include the recently acquired CRSW Lavender

Barrister and Mann
Czech & Speake
Mickey Lee
LA Shaving
I Coloniali
Martin de Candre
La Savonniere du Moulin
Art of Shaving Tallow
Strop Shoppe Limited Edition
Boellis
Eufros Premium
Bufflehead
Chiseled Face
Wool Fat
Tabac
PannaCrema

That's all I've got. Wasn't sure how to count Barrister and Mann as all 4 of the different bases he made are favorites of mine.

First five are in order, after that it's a toss up.

1. Cold River Soap Works
2. Mikes
3. La Savonniere du Moulin
4. Le Pere Lucien
5. Saponificion Varesino

6. Jabonman/Eufros
7. Mitchells Wool Fat
8. Tabac
9. Czech & Speake
10. Klar Seifen
11. I Coloniali
12. Queen Charlotte Soaps
13. Phoenix Artisan Accoutrements
14. Soap Commander
15. Wet Shaving Products/Formula T
16. Martin de Candre
17. RazoRock
18. Arko
19. Cella
20. Art of Shaving/Tallow