Summer Soap Recommendation?

Summer Break Soaps - Cannonball
Noble Otter - Orbit
Stirling - Iced Pineapple
PAA - The Beach

EDIT - Stuck out the ones I listed with Menthol

Some great summer scents- most have menthol to cool you down.
Tangerine Creeper - The Holy Black
Cannonball - Summer break soaps
Terror - Barrister and Mann
Orbit - Noble Otter
Extro - Freddo
Nantahala & Pisgah - Murphy & McNeil
Morning Coffee in the Candian wilderness & Rain 2 - Tallow & Steel
Pink Peppermint - Sudsy Soapery
L' Orange vert set & Asian Plum set - Ariana & Evans
Fujiyama- Daisho

Stirling Satsuma
Spearhead Shaving Seaforth Sea Spiced Lime
Eleven Sicilian Lemon
Stirling Margaritas in the Arctic
Gabels Drops of Lime Aftershave (Off the charts for refreshing)

The OP requesting suggestions for summer soaps specifically noted that he did not want soaps containing menthol. Many summer soaps do.

My face is sensitive to menthol. I tried synthetic menthol. Although it does minimize the irritation; I still get irritation. My skin is also sensitive to peppermint, lime, lemon, and grapefruit scents that are also common in summer scents. I have to be careful of bay rum scents as I am sensitive to clove. I can tolerate low low levels of these scents, but I have to be careful. I do not know whether the OP is sensitive to any of these scents, but it is a possibility. On the other hand, I love scents containing bergamot, mandarin, neroli, and orange.

There are also some floral scents that are good for summer. Yesterday, I shaved with Grooming Dept Kairos Lavender. it is a wonderful sweet lavender scent with no pungent, camphorus undertones. With temperatures as high as 89 degrees F yesterday, the Lavender was a good choice.

It’s a spicy pineapple-y mango musky lite patchouli scent.  It’s unique, very masculine, not sweet.  I’ve been wearing the splash on it’s own, many compliments….

It's my understanding that St Bart's and Island Man are very similar, based on the same cologne or something? If that is correct, what's the difference to your nose?

EDIT: Nevermind, Google answered it. Mind you it's from a post to another forum from 2018 (?), and soap formulas change (get tweaked). Basically, they're both homages to Creed Virgin Island Water . At the time, to the reviewer, Stirling was a bit more synthetic whereas A&E was truer to the original scent. Just in case anyone else was wondering like me...


Sent from my Pixel 4a using Tapatalk

NO Orbit does not contain menthol. It does contain a synthetic cooling agent sometimes called Koolada. Still a cooling sensation without the scent of menthol.

I just ordered and thoroughly enjoying Sphinx Beard (made by Peter Charkalis of A&E) Citrange and Ecstasy. Both dupes but great, light scents.

Others:
Noble Otter Rawr
BM Reserve Cool

Lots of great recommendations. I'm really liking what I read about St Bart's
It would be great if someone would come forward and offer to sell me one (or even part of one)