Help me decide on my next Single-Malt

So I'm a Islay single-malt fan (my go to is Laphroaig 10) and about a dram from finishing my latest bottle. I'm looking for suggestions on where to go next.

So for you peat loving single-malt fans, which of these would you buy?:

• Oban 14
  
• Laphroaig Quarter Cask
  
• Caol Ila 12
  
• Highland Park 12
  
• Ardbeg 10
  
• Lagavulin 16
  

Lagavulin 16

All day, every day.

Everyone needs a bottle of Lagavulin in their liquor cabinet. Lagavulin 16 and probably Ardbeg 10 would be the closest to your "go-to."

Oban (a favorite of mine) and Highland Park 12 (purchased before and will purchase again) would be good choices to diversify..

Laphroaig 10 is my go-to. However, I really like Ardbeg 10 as well.

So I'm a Islay single-malt fan (my go to is Laphroaig 10) and about a dram from finishing my latest bottle.  I'm looking for suggestions on where to go next.

So for you peat loving single-malt fans, which of these would you buy?:

• Oban 14
  
• Laphroaig Quarter Cask
  
• Caol Ila 12
  
• Highland Park 12
  
• Ardbeg 10
  
• Lagavulin 16
  

AA ?

AA ?

I just stopped laughing after an hour or so...great response!

Yes, Moe.

Mom's American Apple pie is well known for its curative powers.

Went with the Lagavulin because the wife said so...

Lagavulin would have been my vote, so you made the right choice.

Hey, I would be able to live with that.