DR Harris, CF or AOS?

Arlington. Without a doubt !

Have only tried the CF, but I'd recommend it. Scent & performance ++

Picked up some CF Lime about a week ago. Loving it. Identical to Tim's old school lime (which was a favorite) to my nose.

I'd vote for DRH Arlington. Great scent.

I'd say Arlington is a must try for the scent - but it is citrus BASED - not a pure citrus - more fougere in my opinion. AOS makes a great cream but the lemon scent is mild. CF creams are polarizing in terms of performance. Some swear by it - others think it's one of the most over-rated - but it seems everyone agrees the lime scent is second to none.

I'm going to be cheeky and suggest DHR Windsor which is  wood, spice, and citrus.  Fantastic scent.  Lovely shaving soap, bath soap, cream, and EDT.
 (I'm a fan)

My vote definitely goes to CF Lime after finally buying a tub and trying it. I did get a little sample of arlington, along with the matching cologne, and I must say I am not a fan at all.

AoS for me. I love their creams. Never really enjoyed the scents of CF and found their performance was OK but nothing special (heresy I know). DRH creams are nice but still just another Creighton cream, prefer their soaps much more.

DRH...another Creighton cream...

Was, but it's now made by another party.

Used CF Lime again today. I truly believe this might be the best cream ever produced.