Pina Colada soap or cream?

Slightly different, Razorock/PAA collaboration The Beach.  Still has coconut but smell more like 80s tanning oil.  Personally I love it.

The Beach is excellent but like you, I don't get Pina Colada. I get suntan lotion (coconut smell is there of course) and just all around smell of a touristy beach. Quite an impressive creation actually.

I'm in the process of making a pina colada soap with rum if it passes my scrutiny I'd be happy to start a pass around

I made beef and vegetable soup last night finished with a Jacque Pepin measure of a Bordeaux, English cheddar and sourdough bread. I'm dining with a tango CD gifted by my new argentine neighbor. And, and I started to wonder if anybody made a soap with that smell.

I made a bacon soap for a member and the guy loves it.

I’ll second the already mentioned Stirling Soap Company Coconut Lime. I just got a sample bar soap in that scent, and while there is no pineapple present, it definitely has some of that piña colada vibe, at least to me (not an expert on the subject, I admit).

Honeybee soaps has a pina colada scent that smells nice. They are by far the best Melt & pour soap I have tried, I think it's due to the shea butter but it doesn't make a bubbly lather like many other m&p soaps, lather consistency is nice and creamy.

I would recommend getting a sample they are 1oz and last a long time, plus many scents to choose from.