Need some opinions - Chatillon Lux vs Cold River Soap Works Aftershaves

Hello! As topic suggested, I would like to have some opinion about the two brands of aftershave mentions if you have any experience with either of them. I lived outside US, so shipping of alcohol aftershaves, is sadly, out of the question. I narrowed down to two different brand

Cold River Soap Works Replenish Post Shave Tonic
Cold River Soap Works Nourish Post Shave Lotion

Chatillon Lux Post-Shave Toner
Chatillon Lux Post-Shave Salve

Would love to hear any opinions. Thank you for your time!