Has anyone used both WSP Black Orchid and Stirling Shadow Orchid?

Hi…

I’m looking for comparisons between WSP’s Black Orchid and Stirling’s Shadow Orchid. Both are based on Tom Ford’s Black Orchid. I have Stirling’s Shadow Orchid, which I like, but don’t love… But I have yet to experience WSP’s Black Orchid and I’m debating on whether or not to buy it. If anyone can offer some comparisons/insight between the two scents, it would certainly be appreciated! 
Thank you 
Justin

I finished up a sample of Stirling Shadow Orchid aftershave a couple of weeks ago and I bought WSP Black Orchid yesterday but haven't used it yet. I liked Shadow Orchid, but not enough to buy it. I can't say what specific difference there is, but I did like Black Orchid enough to buy it.

Without comparing them side-by-side side, I can't tell you why, but I do like WSP's offering better.