Colonia Type Aftershave

I am starting to get low on Acqua di Genova 1853 splash aftershave and can't find any offered retail.  What would you suggest as your idea of the best similar Colonia type aftershave or balm? 

(Asylum Colonia, Lavanda Aqua de Colonia, Alvarez Gomez Emulsion Agua de Colonia, Chatillon Lux Colonia Balsamica, CRSW Colonia Mediterraneo, RazoRock XXX, Fine Italian Citrus, Cella Lotion Splash, TFS Vecchia Torino Acqu di Colonia, Vitos Colonia, Stirling Piacenza, T&S Sicily, etc.)  I need to note that my skin does not tolerate any Acqua di Parma splashes or balms.

Thanks for any thoughts.

For the money Fine cannot be beat IMO.